Route planner vs route optimization software: what is the difference?
Updated
Short answer
A route planner puts the stops of one route in a sensible order and shows the way; route optimization software decides which stop goes to which vehicle, and in what order, while respecting rules such as time windows, capacity, shifts and skills. Vendors use both terms loosely, so check what a product does with your rules. With one driver and a few stops a route planner is enough; with several drivers and rules you need optimization.
How it works in Afi Planner
Two terms, one overlap
There is no standard that separates the words, so read what a product does with your rules rather than what it calls itself.
- Route planner: usually one route and one vehicle. You enter stops, it orders them and gives directions, often as a map tool
- Route optimization software: many stops and many vehicles at once. It assigns and sequences stops under constraints
- Many products say “route planner” and optimize underneath, or say “optimization” and only order one route
What separates them
Four questions tell the two apart in practice.
- Scope: one route, or all drivers at once
- Constraints: delivery windows, service time, capacity, shifts and breaks, skills
- Changes: how a late order or a sick driver is handled
- Dispatch and driver side: sending routes to phones, tracking, proof of delivery and measuring afterward; some tools stop at the plan
| Question | Route planner | Route optimization software |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Route planner: One route and one vehicle at a time | Route optimization software: Every stop and every vehicle of the day at once |
| Who takes which stop | Route planner: You decide | Route optimization software: The software assigns stops to vehicles |
| Rules it applies | Route planner: Stop order, sometimes a time window | Route optimization software: Delivery windows, service time, capacity, shifts and breaks, skills |
| A late order or a sick driver | Route planner: You re-order that route by hand | Route optimization software: It re-plans or fits the change into the routes already out |
| After the plan | Route planner: Directions | Route optimization software: Often dispatch to phones, tracking, proof of delivery and measuring; some tools stop at the plan |
How to choose
Match the tool to your day, then test it on one real day with your own rules and compare with your own routes. The answer on planning routes for multiple drivers has the how-to.
- One driver, few stops, no windows: a route planner is enough
- Several drivers, windows or capacity: route optimization software
- If dispatchers send routes, answer customers and measure results: also check the delivery management features
Where Afi Planner fits
Afi Planner is route planning and delivery management software for local delivery teams, made by Afi Labs. It plans a whole day for every driver in one run with your windows, capacity, skills and shifts, and it explains stops that do not fit. It then sends routes to drivers in Afi Driver or by text link, gives customers a tracking page and measures results in analytics. It is free for three months with no credit card.
Try it in the live demo
A fictional delivery company in the middle of its day. Read-only, no sign-up.
Open the live demo →Feature
Route optimization
Optimize delivery routes for your whole fleet in seconds: time windows, capacity, shifts, breaks and skills, with every unassigned stop explained.
13 steps · 6 min read
How to optimize routes and adjust them by hand
Frequently asked questions
Is a route planner the same as route optimization?
Not always. Check the scope (one route or all drivers) and whether your own rules are applied.
Do I need route optimization for one driver?
Usually not, unless windows, capacity or many stops make the order hard to work out by hand.
What does route optimization software need from me?
Your stops, your drivers and your rules: windows, service time, capacity and shifts.
Does Afi Planner do both?
Yes. It orders the stops of a single route (“Optimize this route”), plans many drivers at once with your rules, and covers the dispatch and driver side too.
More answers
- Can I plan routes from several warehouses or start places?
- What route planning software respects van capacity and delivery windows?
- Can one route do both pickups and deliveries?
- How do I choose route planning software for a small delivery fleet?
- How many delivery drivers do I need for my stops? A calculator
Optimize your own routes
Plan a real day with every driver and constraint on a 3-month free trial, no credit card.
Questions about your setup? Talk to sales